Loading ...

Editor’s Column

We had 4,051 entries submitted to this year’s competition, almost exactly the same as last year. Besides a few more animation pieces than last year, the editorial category had the most submissions we’ve seen in years, debunking the “print is dead” myth.
Go to Jurors Biographies

“I was knocked out by the high quality of the work and the wide range of styles and mediums,” juror Scott McKowen said. “I was pleased to see such strong draftsmanship and painting. As a working illustrator, it really was a humbling (and inspiring) couple of days.”

“Overall, I was impressed with the amount of great work there is out there,” juror Paul Gonzales said. “It made the judging process challenging, but more exciting. So, when someone is picked to be in the Annual, they should be aware of what an honor it truly is.

“I saw some very good work from illustrators I wasn’t familiar with,” juror SooJin Buzelli said. “I’m looking forward to the printed annual so I can get their names and check out more of their work.”

“A feeling of freshness popped up most often around the editorial pieces,” juror Jill Breitbarth said. “Many editorial concepts were drawn in successful ways. A quick look was all that was needed to convey complex ideas, including those around mental illness. There were some real coups. I also liked the amount and quality of silkscreen work, especially in the posters for music and theater. I only wish some of them had been submitted as physical pieces.”

While we allow entries to be submitted in print or digital form, the vast majority are submitted as the latter, a disappointment for several of the jurors.

“I understand that digital entries make sense from a lot of perspectives, but I wish I could have experienced the illustrations as printed objects instead of projected images on screen,” Buzelli said.

Other disappointments? “I wish I had seen more animation—I know the animators are out there,” juror James Zucco said.

“The work published in the book is always a very impressive collection. After seeing the judging process, I’m even more impressed with the selected work.” —SooJin Buzelli

“I was surprised and disappointed that some established illustrators didn’t enter their work. I guess that leaves the door open for new illustrators, which was nice to see,” Gonzales said.

“Many illustrations in the self-promotion and unpublished categories were of violent fantasy worlds,” Breitbarth said. “Straight-up portraits and realistic illustrations were in the minority. What are we to glean from that?”

I asked the jurors where they thought the field of illustration is headed?

“I think one of the directions the field of illustration could be headed is ‘motion illustration,’” Gonzales said. “This is not necessarily animation, but movement that will further engage readers in the world of interactive electronic publications.”

“I’m excited to see how illustrators will continue to mash up digital techniques with traditional, hand-drawn/hand-painted ones,” Zucco said.

“This sounds glib, but the field seems in very good hands, from the work we have seen here,” McKowen said. “We live in a more visually-aware culture than we did ten years ago (hard to tell where one renaissance of illustration leaves off and the next one begins). Acute, sophisticated concepts can be conveyed through simple, eloquent images—and readers and audiences are more receptive, more tuned-in to them than ever before. The bar just keeps getting raised.”

“I was surprised how many of my favorite pieces involved music: concert posters, album cover art, etc.” —James Zucco

The jurors worked in two groups of three with Jean Coyne acting as the sixth judge during the screening. All categories had been divided so each team screened half of the entries submitted. The judges alternated between viewing a session of projected digital files and then a setup of print entries. Any juror could place an illustration in the finals by handing a printed piece to a member of our staff. Digital files were screened by checking the “in” or “out” column on prepared scoring sheets.

The final voting took place on Monday with all five jurors working together. Print entries were again spread out on the tables. Two paper cups, one white for “in,” the other red for “out,” with slots cut in the bottom, were placed upside down to the right of the pieces. The jurors voted by putting a different colored tile into the bottom of the appropriate cup. The different colored tiles allowed us to make sure that every entry was voted on by every judge. Finalists submitted as digital files were again voted on by each juror checking “in” or “out” on scoring sheets. A simple majority was required for acceptance.

Judges were not permitted to vote on projects they were directly involved in creating. When a judge’s piece was in the finals, either Jean or I would cast the fifth vote.

I would like to thank each of the judges for their conscientious efforts in selecting our 53rd Annual Exhibition. —Patrick Coyne ca

Jurors Biographies
Jill Breitbarth
senior designer
Harvard University Press
Jill Breitbarth is senior designer at Harvard University Press, where she has worked for almost seventeen years. During Breitbarth's tenure in academic publishing (she previously worked at Yale University Press), she has been especially interested in working out innovative ways to synthesize and visually present difficult ideas. Her jackets and covers for HUP books have won New England Book Show awards and an AIGA 50 Books/50 Covers award, among other honors. Breitbarth's other visual interests include people-watching, rock collecting and travel-the legacy of a childhood spent overseas.
SooJin Buzelli
creative director
Asset International
SooJin Buzelli is an award-winning creative director with fifteen years experience art directing and designing magazines. She is currently the senior vice president, creative director of Asset International where she designs and art directs many of Asset International's products, including Plansponsor, Planadviser, Plansponsor Europe and aiCIO magazines. She also is a board member of The Illustration Conference 7 (ICON7). Buzelli holds an Illustration BFA from Rhode Island School of Design.
Paul Gonzales
deputy design director
Los Angeles Times
Paul Gonzales is a deputy design director for the features department at the Los Angeles Times. As such, he leads a team of designers in producing the newspaper's lively and creative Sunday Calendar Arts & Books, Travel and Health sections. In his twenty-plus-year career at the Times, he has won many awards for design, art direction and photo illustration from such prestigious organizations as Communication Arts, Print, SND and SPD. His collaboration with illustrators has also resulted in a number of award-winning pieces. Gonzales's quiet resolve and passion for design and illustration comes through loud and clear in his work. He is proud to be part of a core team that has helped develop the design of the Los Angeles Times into one of the most highly awarded in the world.
Scott McKowen
illustrator/designer/art director
Punch & Judy Inc
Scott McKowen is an award-winning illustrator, graphic designer and art director. Born and raised in Michigan, he is based in Stratford, Ontario, Canada, where he operates the small design studio Punch & Judy Inc, which has created theatre posters and graphics for leading performing arts companies across North America. McKowen has illustrated a series of children's classics for Sterling Publishing, which now includes 32 titles. He has illustrated books and covers for Harper Collins, Marvel, Penguin, Quirk, Random House, St. Martins and Tor. McKowen specializes in scratchboard, an engraving medium in which white lines are carved into a black surface with a sharp blade; in 2009, Firefly Books published A Fine Line: Scratchboard Illustrations by Scott McKowen.
James Zucco
associate creative director
Barrie D'Rozario Murphy
James Zucco is an internationally-recognized advertising art director. Since graduating from the University of Texas at Austin in 1996, Zucco has created award-winning work for blue-chip clients in almost every industry. He is currently an associate creative director at Barrie D'Rozario Murphy in Minneapolis, which he joined after years of working with Barrie and D'Rozario at Fallon Worldwide. His work has been featured in the Cannes Festival, Communication Arts, D&AD, New York Art Directors Club and the One Show. His commercial for Travelers Insurance received an Emmy nomination in 2006, and two of his commercials for United Airlines are in the permanent collection at MoMA. Zucco lives in Edina, Minnesota, with his wife, Bethany, and their yellow Labrador, Roxy.

With a free Commarts account, you can enjoy 50% more free content
Create an Account
Get a subscription and have unlimited access
Already a subscriber or have a Commarts account?
Sign In

Get a subscription and have unlimited access
Already a subscriber?
Sign In